Field Report · Missed-Call Test

We Called 50 Bookkeeping Firms After Hours. 9 Calls Reached a Person.

We placed one after-hours call to each of 50 bookkeeping firms in 11 East Coast states. 9 calls reached a person at the firm. 35 went to voicemail or a recorded greeting, and 3 numbers were disconnected. It's one after-hours call per firm, so read it as a snapshot.

At a glance

MeasureResult
Firms called50
Calls that reached a person at the firm9 of 50
Went to voicemail or a recorded greeting35
Number disconnected3
Automated system, rang out or busy3

What happened on each call

OutcomeCalls
A person at the firm picked up9
Voicemail or recorded greeting35
Automated system, nobody came on the line1
Number disconnected3
Rang out, no answer1
Busy signal1

The first row is the 9 calls that reached the firm. The other five rows are the 41 that did not.

What we noticed

  • Voicemail was the default. 35 of 50 calls ended at a voicemail or a recorded greeting.
  • 9 calls reached a person. 1 was the owner and 5 were someone else at the firm. For the other 3, the log doesn't say who picked up.
  • The smallest firms went to voicemail. 10 of the 11 firms listing one or two employees did.
  • An automated system isn't an answer. 1 call was routed by an automated message to the owner's line, and nobody came on.
  • 3 numbers were disconnected. The number on file no longer connects.

What this means if you run a bookkeeping firm

A business owner looking for a bookkeeper may be calling after their own workday ends. Run the same test on your own firm and find out what they hear.

  • Call your own number. Use a phone your team won't recognize. Try once at lunch, once after close and once on a Saturday.
  • Write down what happens. Who picks up, how long it rings, and whether you can leave a message.
  • Listen to your voicemail greeting. 35 of our 50 calls ended at one. Make sure yours is set up, isn't full, and tells a caller when they'll hear back.
  • Check every listing. Dial the number on your website, your Google profile and your directory listings. 3 of the numbers we had on file no longer connect.

Want to know what your callers hear?

Book a free Find My Missed Revenue review. James looks at how your calls, forms and follow-up are handled and shows you where revenue is slipping.

Find My Missed Revenue →

How we did it

  • The calls: one first call per firm, placed between 3 p.m. and 7 p.m. ET on Nov 17, Nov 18 and Nov 19, 2026 by a member of our outreach team to the phone number on file for that firm. The caller logged what happened on each call.
  • The firms: 50 bookkeeping, accounting and outsourced CFO firms, listing between 1 and 10 employees. 11 list one or two employees.
  • Where: Florida 13, New York 12, Georgia 6, Maryland 4, Pennsylvania 4, Massachusetts 3, North Carolina 3, Delaware 2, and 1 each in New Jersey, South Carolina and Virginia.
  • Follow-up calls: some firms were called again later, during business hours. Those calls aren't counted here. They reached a person at 3 more of these firms.
  • Names: no firm is named here. A firm we called can ask us for its own result.

What this test can't tell you

  • It's a snapshot, not an answer rate. One call per firm shows what happened once. A firm that missed this call may answer the next.
  • This was an after-hours test. Each first call was placed after closing time. It shows what an evening caller gets, not what happens during the workday.
  • The numbers came from a business contact list. They weren't checked against each firm's website. Several of these firms are one or two people, so the number may be the owner's own phone.
  • These were outreach calls. A business owner calling for help with their books may get further than we did.

We report what our caller logged. We don't rank, rate or name any firm.